The Innocent Idealist and Angry Activist

One of the most hotly debated terms this century is the word woke. It means to be aware, as in, “I have woke up to [this cause].” Formerly, you were not aware; now, you are. Woke is most often used in the context of what some folks believe are the oppressors and the oppressed: “I am awake to your oppression.” Within this group of woke people, you will find a spectrum of adherents. On one end, there are the innocent idealists, and on the other, there are angry activists.

You may want to read:

Woke Origins

It is theologically fair to say the first woke people were Adam and Eve. They were doing pretty well in the Garden of Eden before the walking, talking, oppressive serpent opened their eyes to another way of thinking about God, life, each other, and social causes. In Genesis 3:6, Adam and Eve became woke. The idea of woke has been around for several millennia and used in different ways. It appears that the modern expression of woke entered common speech in 2008 in the black community.

In today’s culture, wokeness has glommed onto itself a specific and intensified meaning. You can be woke about many things, though most of the time, people connect their wokeness to the social justice movement. More on that later. To trace wokeness to its modern origins, you would go back to the Frankfurt School in the 1930s, where you’ll learn about Critical Theory (CT)—the roots of woke—and many other synonymous social ideas and constructs.

Frankfurt School

The Frankfurt School was a collection of smart misfits who did not adhere to capitalism or communism’s unbending framework. This group of intellectuals believed there was a better way to think about social advancement. They did this by tying themselves to Marxism, not so much with Karl Marx’s economic ideas but a Marxist sociological worldview. To be woke, in today’s use of the word, means your presuppositional starting point begins in a social Marxist ideology.

Most woke people don’t know their woke history, which is one reason many Christians are jumping on the woke wagon. This disconnect in understanding is why woke gainsayers need to understand that all woke people are not created equally. In the context of this chapter, I have on one end of the woke spectrum, the innocent idealists. On the other end is the scold mob, whom I call the angry activists. If you asked the innocent idealist about the presuppositional roots of wokeness, they could not tell you. Someone gave them a poster and said, “Go stand [over there].” They have never heard of the Frankfurt School, Critical Theory, or Karl Marx.

Roots Matter

What they need to understand is that if they begin with a presuppositional Marxist philosophy on social issues, their activism will be consistent with Karl Marx. The result will be something different from the Bible’s endpoint. Most culturally woke people—I assume—do not understand how presuppositions determine their activism and the linear results that flow from that starting point. Because of this lack of awareness, Christians need to respond with humility and intelligence to the innocently unaware. Imagine someone yelling at you about your ignorance before God woke you up to your lostness (Ephesians 2:1-5).

Condemnation strategies may work for a few but not the entire unregenerate or woke communities. Think about how you came to Christ. You were born in Adam, totally depraved, a dirty, rotten sinner, with no hope of understanding or changing (1 Corinthians 2:14; John 3:7; Romans 3:10-12, 10:9, 13). From that presuppositional starting point, you grew up as an unregenerate child, acting out according to your Adamic nature. The results would have been hell if you had not become woken in Christ (Revelation 20:15).

A Tree with Branches

The presuppositional root of the woke tree starts with the communist Karl Marx, who gives us critical theory (CT) about social issues. From there, the CT tree grows into many branches. Some of these limbs intersect with each other, while others do not. To borrow another metaphor, think of Critical Theory as a bowl of soup; inside the container are many social constructs. Here are a few.

• Critical Race Theory (CRT): The idea that laws, institutions, and structures are systemically racist and must change fundamentally.
• Intersectionality: The study that any aspect of a person’s identity—e.g., race, gender, class—can be an advantage or disadvantage. A black, gay female is part of three disadvantaged groups, according to the theory. She’s not as privileged as a white, gay female.
• Wokeness: The person who opens their eyes to see societal ills through the lens of Critical Theory.
• Queer Theory: A strand of Critical Theory that teaches a person how to think about or practice being gay.
• Identity Politics: Believing your identity is the primary way you should think of yourself, e.g., black, LGBTQ+, trans, female, etc.
• Social Justice: Bringing social equality to all vulnerable, weaker, smaller, or less powerful groups.
• White Privilege: Opportunities that white people have and that minorities—people of color (POC)—do not.
• Hegemonic Power: The dominance of the more influential group exerting power and authority over the less dominant. This group is the oppressor class.

There are many more Critical Theory constructs, but you get the idea. Those who have given more time to this will provide more intelligent definitions for all of these concepts, but I hope this gives you a basic thumbnail sketch and a path forward to think about and care for the woke soul.

The Big Idea

The running theme through all of these constructs is two people groups—the oppressors and the oppressed. If you go back through the shortlist of Critical Theory constructs, you will see how these two antithetical groups conflict. For example, our current cultural crisis is racism. The whites are the hegemonic power (oppressors), and the blacks are the oppressed. Slavery is the proof in the pudding, according to those who beat the Critical Theory drum. No rational person denies the atrocities of slavery, though that time in our dark history is not as black and white as some folks want to make it today.

There is complexity with slavery in America, but if your motivation is not as objective as it should be, you will not entertain those complexities. You will stay stuck in a cycle of victimness and hate. The mind-boggling good news is that we abolished slavery and have been progressively removing those evil barriers that kept men and women from a fair shot at the American dream. Because our founding fathers believed in the teachings of Scripture, even though many of them were not Christians, they framed our country with the best possibilities for success. Anyone who takes an honest look at our country’s 200-year trend will see this ever-progressing miracle.

Innocent Idealists

But we have flaws. If you put 340+ million sinners in a room, bad things will happen. Like the parent who cannot see a child’s positive progression, too many woke people highlight only our negative traits, even if it means tearing down the structures that provided the framework that gives them the freedom and platform to demolish our country. We see the disintegrating of the structures in every corner of our society, including the church.

There are hordes of social justice warriors lashing out within our churches, seeking to bring correction (or tear down) the system. It is no accident that these justice seekers run contemporary with what is happening in the culture. They are not wrong in the sense that we have problems in our house. Abuses are everywhere. I am as attuned to abusive people, churches, and denominations as anyone. I have not disregarded these things, but it has never occurred to me to remake the body of Christ or its local manifestations.

Sloganeering Bait

The fingerprints of Satan are all over these justice movements, whether inside or outside the church. There is a reason the Bible talks about the devil as an angel of light (2 Corinthians 11:14). I am not saying that these innocent idealists are satanic or even unregenerate. What person has not been duped by the devil? The devil’s plan has not changed since he woke up Adam and Eve, and he will not leave us alone either. We all have our guilt, so there’s no need to duck: I’m not tossing stones at anyone. Part of his angel of light strategy is in his sloganeering. There is always just enough embedded truth in the Critical Theory mantras to allure any of us.

Who believes that black lives do not matter? No rational person. How clever to say, “Black Lives Matter,” but when you look under the hood of that organization, you see a Marxist group who explicitly states their hope to destroy the nuclear family. Or, how can you argue against social justice? Shouldn’t all Christians strive to treat all people in all social constructs with fairness? The problem is that these social justice warriors inside the church, whether innocent or not, are tearing down the historical church structure and installing a worldview that has its roots in Karl Marx, the Frankfurt School, and Critical Theory.

Angry Activists

As you move across the spectrum of proponents of the Critical Theory, you will eventually run into the most hostile of these adherents. They are angry, vindictive, anti-God, and would feel no sympathy if a white person were to become a casualty of this culture war. I will not illustrate their hate speech here, but if you’re interested, you may jump on nearly any social platform to hear the cliches and vitriol. These warriors are not unaware Marxists. They want to destroy America and any other country that believes differently from them. They are the angry cancel culture on steroids. As the non-peaceful protests of 2020 demonstrated, they are not hiding the ball. They want to destroy any person or group that can exert power over them, e.g., police, white people, men, etc.

They won’t acknowledge how it’s only a minority within all of these groups who are abusive. For example, Robin DiAngelo teaches all white people are guilty of racism in her wildly popular book, White Fragility. According to her, if you admit you are a racist, you’re guilty—whether your admission was genuine or you caved to gaslighting. If you deny that you’re a racist, you prove your guilt by your denial. It is a non-falsifiable circularity, along the lines of the Salem Witch Trials: throw a witch in a pond; if she drowns, she is not a witch; if she walks on water, she is a witch, so they burn her at the stake. Either way, she dies.

Don’t Be a Denier

The innocent idealists will do similarly to the angry activists, though they will accomplish their goals with less vitriol. Those who adhere, ignorantly or not, to Critical Theory do so because they believe in their version of utopia. The word means no place; it does not exist. It would be great if our marriages, churches, workplaces, and culture were better than they are now, but we know that the Bible narrative teaches a sinful world that Christ came to redeem. If you look at the lives of authentic Christians, you will see this progressive transformation. What you won’t see is perfection.

For us imperfect Christians who do believe and follow the Bible, we cannot deny that there is some truth in what the CT activists are saying. What you don’t want to do is make the mistake of saying “all social justice warriors are evil” by clumping every social justice adherent into the same camp. It’s sophomoric to think in such terms. Don’t stop influencing, but do it the right way. Ask the Lord to give you the courage to stand on your platform, no matter its size. Too many Christians are afraid to speak out; they want to be left alone, but we do not have that option. We have a light and some salt in our knapsacks. Jesus appeals to us to use those redemptive tools for God’s glory and the benefit of as many who will hear, submit, and follow.

Call to Action

Will you do four things in response to this chapter?

1. Study Critical Theory and its constructs.
2. Continue to examine yourself, but not in an overly introspective, navel-gazing way. Ask God to give you appropriate biblical clarity about where you are with these matters.
3. As you are educating yourself and examining your soul, talk to those within your peer group. You will have to guide some of them. Others will be able to have mature, reciprocal conversations with you.
4. Ask the Lord to give you the humility, wisdom, compassion, and courage to influence those who could use your help.

Need More Help?

1. If you want to learn more from us, you may search this site for thousands of resources—articles, podcasts, videos, graphics, and more. Please spend time studying the ones that interest you. They are free.
2. If you want to talk to us, we have private forums for those who support this ministry financially. Please consider supporting us here if you would like to help us keep our resources free.

Rick launched the Life Over Coffee global training network in 2008 to bring hope and help for you and others by creating resources that spark conversations for transformation. His primary responsibilities are resource creation and leadership development, which he does through speaking, writing, podcasting, and educating.

In 1990 he earned a BA in Theology and, in 1991, a BS in Education. In 1993, he received his ordination into Christian ministry, and in 2000 he graduated with an MA in Counseling from The Master’s University. In 2006 he was recognized as a Fellow of the Association of Certified Biblical Counselors (ACBC).